These Halloween Peanut Butter Witch Fingers are Finger-Licking Good.

Questify Top Stories


This Halloween, when the witch tries to steal from the cookie jar, just turn her fingers into cookies! That’s what we did for this scary-delicious, super simple Halloween recipe. Who knew that witches had the craveable and enticing flavor of peanut butter cookies? Certainly not us, we’re just glad they do. Take a look at the full recipe below and join in the delicious festivities tonight!




Yields: 7 servings | Serving Size:  1 finger

Calories: 100 | Protein: 9g  | Fat: 4.5g | Net Carb: 3

Total Carb: 11g | Fiber: 3g

Prep Time: 15 mins  | Cook Time: 6-8 mins | Total Time:  30mins (including cooling/decorating time)



  • 2 Quest Peanut Butter Protein Cookies
  • 1 Scoop Quest Vanilla Milkshake Protein Powder
  • 2 tbsp oat flour
  • 2 tbsp zero calorie sweetener
  • 1 egg, large
  • 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
  • Pinch of sea salt
  • 13 pieces of slivered almonds
  • 2-3 drops red food coloring


  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit and prepare a baking sheet with parchment paper
  2. Place the cookies into a food processor and blend until fine crumbles form.
  3. Transfer cookie crumbles to a mixing bowl.
  4. Add in the protein powder, oat flour, sweetener and salt. Stir until combined.
  5. Add the egg and vanilla to the mixture and stir until a dough forms.
  6. Separate the dough into 14 evenly sized balls.
  7. Shape each ball out into a finger shape, roughly the size of a pinky finger.
  8. Add a slivered almond to the top where the fingernail would be and place the dough on the baking sheet.
  9. bake until golden brown, remove from the oven and let cool.
  10. Once cooled drop 2-3 drops of red food coloring onto a plate and dip the end of a toothpick to add blood coloring to fingers.
  11. Enjoy!